"The game rocks I think the best part is the family spellbook only because on a show charmed they have a family spellbook I dont even care it is the last sims expansion pack coming out but up ahead sims2" - Michael

"Personally I think this is one of the best Sims expansion pack. You have more to do and more goals. Like you need 1000 magicoins to move to Magic Town and when move into your house you only get 35. Its also fun trying to find ways to get what you need for a special spell. Thats not all but if haven't got or played this game you dont know what you're missin! - KK

"oh i love this game so much i love the spellbook alot and i like that the kids have magic too oh and i like that you can turn people into toads" - Amy

"I love the sims Makin' Magic, its the best one yet! Taking care of the dragons is so much fun!Plus they have so many goals, more to do and everything! You should give it a shot if you haven't already. The spell book is lots of fun too!" - LaLeebear

"Very good expansion pack. At first when I heard about it, I was thinking "ah, they've gone into the whole 'magic' thing, it'll be dumb." Yes, they are doing the whole "magic" thing, but no, it isn't dumb. It's fun. The spells are useful, for the most part. Though a spell that makes your skill levels go up would be nice...But it's creative and even if you think the whole magic thing is dumb, it adds on a LOT of new stuff. Mostly gypsy style, but it's old-fashioned so good if you want a house like that. Plus, now you can cook. You can make "nectars", bread, cake, pies and stuff. Just make sure you have about level 5 or 6 cooking points first. And the Magic Town is cool, you can have your Sims move in-for a price-or it's just another town thing like Downtown, Superstarland, Vacation place etc. Magic Town is where your Sims can buy the magic ingredients. I think it's a very fun last expansion pack, it'll keep ya busy till the Sims 2 (hopefully)." - Holly Megan

"The Sims Makin' Magic is great . I love the whole magicthing. The spells,thr abilities, the NPC's,and the whole new Magic Town.Out of 10 I rate this 9. It's is the best expansion since Superstar , but better, way better. Even though they need more spells and more ways to display your magical power.Still this game rocks." - Blue